Credit history is proving to be a major stumbling block for prospective tenants, with new research revealing that almost a third of failed rental applications are linked to adverse credit records. According to fresh analysis from lettings platform Propoly, around 30% of rejected tenant references include at least one adverse-credit marker, while County Court Judgments (CCJs) alone feature in 14.8% of declined applications. The findings highlight the importance of thorough tenant referencing and the challenges landlords face when assessing prospective tenants.
However, the findings also show that most applicants successfully complete the referencing process, with only 6.4% failing outright.
Approximately 62% of applicants pass their checks on the first attempt, while a further 29% receive conditional approval, allowing some tenants to proceed by meeting additional requirements.
Affordability remains the main reason for referencing failures
Despite the impact of credit history, affordability remains the most common primary reason for unsuccessful tenant referencing applications.
Propoly’s analysis found that affordability concerns accounted for 31.8% of declined applications, followed by adverse credit history at 29.4%.
Insufficient or unverified proof of income contributed to 19.7% of declines, while employment-related factors, including short-term contracts, accounted for 6.2%.
Meanwhile, suspected fraud represented just 0.8% of declined applications.
The findings highlight the importance of assessing applicants’ financial circumstances and obtaining appropriate supporting documentation during the referencing process.
Guarantors help applicants meet affordability requirements
The research also demonstrates how conditional approvals can help prospective tenants who do not initially meet standard affordability criteria.
Of the applications assessed for affordability, 15.2% failed the initial check. However, only 9.5% of these applicants were ultimately declined outright.
Around 54% received conditional approval, often through a guarantor or other additional requirements, while approximately 35% passed the overall referencing process.
For landlords, guarantors can provide an alternative option when applicants do not independently meet affordability requirements.
This is particularly relevant within the student accommodation sector, where tenants may have limited employment income or credit history and rely on financial support from parents or guardians.
Previous credit issues may not reflect current circumstances
Sim Sekhon, Group Chief Executive at Propoly, explained that historical financial difficulties can continue to affect prospective tenants even when their circumstances have improved.
“With the cost of living continuing to put pressure on household finances, it is perhaps unsurprising that credit history is playing a significant role in tenant referencing outcomes.”
He added that a failed referencing check does not necessarily prevent a tenancy from proceeding, with guarantors and conditional approvals potentially providing alternative arrangements.
What does this mean for student landlords?
For student landlords, the findings highlight the importance of considering individual financial circumstances when reviewing tenancy applications.
Students may not have established credit histories or regular employment income, meaning traditional affordability assessments may not fully reflect their financial arrangements.
Requesting supporting documentation early, considering suitable guarantors and applying consistent referencing criteria can help landlords make informed decisions.
Landlords should also ensure that referencing procedures and guarantor agreements comply with relevant housing and equality legislation.
Overall, Propoly’s findings suggest that although affordability and credit history remain significant factors, most applicants successfully complete referencing.
For student landlords, a balanced and proportionate approach can help assess potential financial risks while ensuring applicants are considered fairly.
Source: Propoly rental intelligence data on tenant referencing outcomes.



